When and Why to Change Trustees: A Guide for Financial Advisors
Choosing the right trustee is a crucial decision that can impact the success of one’s trust administration. When drafting trusts and estate planning documents, grantors have the choice of an individual trustee, traditional trustee, or independent corporate trustee:
- Individual trustees are often family members with little oversight or experience in trust administration.
- A traditional trustee assumes control over the management of trust assets and all administrative responsibilities of the trust.
- An independent, directed corporate trustee focuses solely on trust and estate administration, allowing families to continue working with their trusted advisors.
Since trustees are selected at the initiation of a trust, changing circumstances over time may necessitate reevaluating the suitability of the chosen trustee.
Take, for instance, the case of a family trust managed by a traditional bank. The beneficiaries receive their distributions for years with little interaction from the trustee. Over time, the beneficiaries experience a lack of communication and client service. Investment performance is poor, and requests for information or distributions are often met with delays. The beneficiaries feel disconnected from the trustee and their family’s wealth, leading them to seek alternatives.
Many beneficiaries inherit trustees they had no part in selecting, and these trustees may not align with their needs or expectations. Financial advisors are likely to encounter clients who are dissatisfied with their trustee but unaware of the alternative options available. Changing a trustee can seem daunting, but understanding the nuances of trustee changes can lead to more effective trust administration and improved client satisfaction.
Determine the Need for a Trustee Change
Understanding when and why to make a change of trustee is key to ensuring the trust continues to be managed effectively and aligns with the beneficiaries’ needs and goals.
Common Reasons for Change:
1. Trustee’s Incapacity or Unwillingness to Serve: Individual trustees may face health or personal challenges preventing them from effectively fulfilling their duties. Sometimes, they may no longer wish to bear the responsibilities involved.
2. Personal Conflicts or Lack of Impartiality: Conflicts between beneficiaries and trustees can arise from various sources, including disagreements over management decisions or perceived favoritism. Trustees are expected to act impartially and in the best interests of all beneficiaries. Some trustees may struggle with bias, leading to dissatisfaction among beneficiaries.
3. Lackluster Investment Performance: Effective asset management is crucial for the growth and preservation of trust assets. If a trustee lacks the expertise to manage investments properly, the trust’s performance may suffer.
4. Errors in Administration: Accurate and timely distributions are often fundamental trustee duties. Errors in distribution or lapses in accounting can cause financial losses and erode trust in the trustee’s competence.
5. Inattentive Client Service: Failure to communicate regularly and transparently with beneficiaries can lead to mistrust and dissatisfaction.
Evaluate the Current Trustee
Before making any decisions about changing a trustee, it is essential to thoroughly evaluate the current trustee’s performance and adherence to the trust document. This involves a multi-faceted review to ensure that the trustee is fulfilling their responsibilities effectively and in the best interest of the beneficiaries.
1. Review the Trust Document
When evaluating the current trustee, it is important to review the terms, limitations, and powers granted to the trustee outlined in the trust document. Understanding these details is required because they dictate the trustee’s responsibilities and the scope of their authority. Key points to consider include:
- Modification Clauses: Determine if the trust document allows for the removal and replacement of the trustee. Some documents may have specific conditions or stipulations that must be met.
- Trustee Powers: Assess the powers granted to the trustee regarding asset management, distributions, and other critical decisions.
- Beneficiary Rights: Understand the rights and protections afforded to beneficiaries, including their ability to request information or challenge the trustee’s actions.
2. Assess Performance and Service
A thorough assessment of the trustee’s performance involves evaluating several aspects of their service:
- Communication and Responsiveness: Effective communication is a cornerstone of successful trust administration. The trustee should maintain regular, timely, and transparent communication with beneficiaries and other stakeholders.
- Investment Management: Evaluate the trustee’s investment strategies and aptitude for preserving and growing the trust’s value:
- Are the investments aligned with the trust’s goals and risk tolerance?
- Is the trustee providing regular performance reports and justifications for their investment choices?
- How has the trust’s portfolio performed relative to relevant benchmarks?
- Distribution Accuracy and Timeliness: Review whether distributions were made according to the trust document’s terms and how the trustee handles requests for distribution.
- Record-Keeping and Accounting Practices: Financial records and accounts should be up-to-date and accurately maintained. The trustee should provide clear, detailed accounting reports.
Understand the Process of Changing Trustees
Understanding the intricacies of changing a trustee is important for financial advisors and beneficiaries. The process varies significantly between revocable and irrevocable trusts, each with its own set of legal requirements and limitations.
- Revocable Trusts: In the case of revocable trusts, the grantor retains significant control over the trust. This includes the ability to modify the trust document, including changing the trustee, as long as the grantor is alive and has the capacity to do so. This flexibility allows the grantor to easily respond to changes in circumstances or preferences.
- Irrevocable Trusts: Irrevocable trusts are more rigid by design. Once established, any changes, including trustee removal and replacement, are governed by the terms of the trust document and state laws. Beneficiaries may have the power to initiate a trustee change depending on various factors.
Steps to Change Trustees
Changing a trustee involves several steps to ensure a smooth and legally compliant transition. Here is an overview of what beneficiaries can typically expect:
1. Evaluate Alternative Trustees: Contact potential new trustees to understand more about their services and how they work with beneficiaries and their professional advisors.
2. Review the Trust Document for Change Provisions: The trust document will outline the specific conditions and procedures for changing a trustee. It is important to thoroughly review these provisions to understand the available options and limitations.
3. Consult With an Estate Planning Attorney: Any actions taken to change a trustee must comply with the relevant state laws. This includes reviewing the trust document to understand the jurisdictional implications and ensuring all legal requirements are met. An estate planning attorney specializes in interpreting trust documents, navigating legal requirements, and advising on the best course of action.
4. Understand State Laws Regarding Trustee Changes: In some states, beneficiaries may be able to change trustees without lengthy court proceedings through Non-Judicial Settlement Agreements (NJSAs). These agreements allow beneficiaries to settle matters related to the trust, including trustee changes, through mutual consent, thereby saving time and legal expenses.
5. Prepare Necessary Documents and Facilitate the Transition: Once the decision to change the trustee is made, all the necessary legal documents to formalize the transition must be prepared. This may include resignation letters from the current trustee, removal or acceptance letters from the new trustee, and any required court filings. The estate planning attorney will facilitate this process to ensure it meets all legal and procedural requirements.
Consider all the Options
While it’s common to default to an individual or traditional corporate trustee option, the directed trustee model offers the advantages of flexibility and control while alleviating many of the burdens associated with traditional trust management. In this model, the trustee is responsible for the trust administration while an appointed financial advisor directs the investment decisions. This separation of duties allows for a tailored and efficient management of trust assets while eliminating the conflict of interest that can occur when the trustee manages investments held in trust.
We’re Here to Help
Contact us to learn how we can partner with you to provide exceptional trust and estate administration services and ensure your clients’ peace of mind.
Choosing the right trustee is essential, but understanding that change is possible can significantly benefit trust management. If you or your clients are considering a trustee change, remember that you have options and resources available. Consult with us and explore the benefits of the directed trustee model.
At Cumberland Trust, we are dedicated to partnering with financial advisors and their clients in navigating the complexities of trust administration.